
In today’s lending environment, automation and artificial intelligence (AI) are transforming how lenders evaluate borrowers and make credit decisions. While these technologies offer greater efficiency and consistency, they cannot always capture the full story behind a loan. At RFG, we believe the most effective approach combines the speed and analytical capabilities of AI with the experience, judgment, and common-sense approach of manual underwriting.
Understanding the Underwriting Process
Underwriting is the process of evaluating a borrower’s credit history, stated income, assets, and collateral to determine creditworthiness and assess the risk associated with a loan. At RFG, our primary objective is to measure risk and ensure that borrowers have the ability and resources to fulfill their loan obligations.
Because RFG’s primary product allows real estate investors to finance 100% of their purchase and rehabilitation costs, a thorough review of every borrower is essential. This financing structure makes it particularly important to understand the borrower’s overall financial position, experience, and ability to successfully complete a project.
Although our process involves a deeper review of the borrower’s profile, we remain committed to efficiency. By combining a comprehensive manual underwriting process with AI-assisted analysis, RFG can continue to underwrite files efficiently and close loans within 10 business days.
The Human Element: How RFG Manually Underwrites a Loan
Manual underwriting allows our team to look beyond individual data points and evaluate the broader circumstances surrounding a loan. We focus on four primary areas: credit, stated income, assets, and collateral.
Credit History and FICO Scores
We begin by reviewing the borrower’s FICO scores from the three major credit bureaus. However, the score itself is only part of the analysis. Our underwriters also examine the details behind the number, including late payments, credit utilization, bankruptcies, foreclosures, judgments, collections, and charge-offs.
Understanding these factors helps us determine whether a borrower’s credit score accurately reflects their overall risk. A lower score does not automatically mean a borrower is a poor lending candidate; the circumstances contributing to that score matter.
Stated Income
Next, we evaluate the borrower’s stated income to determine whether it is reasonable and consistent with their employment circumstances. This includes considering the employer, position, and length of time the borrower has held that position.
The goal is to assess whether the reported income makes sense within the context of the borrower’s professional background and financial profile.
Assets and Bank Statements
Asset verification is another critical component of our process. RFG reviews three months of bank statements for each account submitted, examining opening balances, deposits, withdrawals, and ending balances.
Our team looks for inconsistencies that may require further investigation, such as unexplained discrepancies, formatting irregularities, an ending balance that does not match the following month’s opening balance, or identical transaction activity across consecutive months.
These details help us develop a clearer understanding of the borrower’s available funds and identify potential concerns before making a lending decision.
Collateral and Property Valuation
The property itself is equally important to our risk assessment. RFG orders full appraisals for every file, and depending on the transaction, a feasibility study may also be required.
Our team reviews comparable sales to determine whether they are similar to the subject property, whether the adjustments are consistent with general market acceptance, and whether the comparable properties are located an appropriate distance from the subject property.
In addition to the property’s as-is value, RFG considers its after-repair value (ARV) when determining the appropriate loan amount. This is particularly important for investment properties that require rehabilitation, where the projected value following completion of the work plays a significant role in evaluating the transaction.
A Common-Sense Approach to Risk
The central principle behind RFG’s manual underwriting process is simple: we want to understand the full picture before making a final decision. Consider a borrower with extensive real estate investment experience, strong assets, and a proven ability to complete projects, but a FICO score that is lower than expected. A review focused solely on the credit score might overlook the borrower’s strengths and history of successfully fulfilling financial obligations.
Manual underwriting allows us to consider those additional factors when assessing the overall risk. Rather than relying on a single metric, we evaluate the borrower’s complete profile and use sound judgment to determine whether the loan makes sense.
This approach does not mean overlooking potential risks. Instead, it means understanding them in context and making informed decisions based on the available information.
AI as a Second Layer of Review
Once our team completes the manual underwriting process, we use AI as an additional review tool. The objective is to confirm that the AI-assisted review supports the underwriter’s decision and does not identify any material findings that have been overlooked. A material finding is an issue that could affect the underwriting decision, including the loan amount, interest rate, or borrower eligibility.
For example, suppose a loan was priced based on a FICO score of 750, but a review reveals that the borrower’s actual middle score is 650. That discrepancy could materially affect the loan terms and potentially change whether RFG can approve the transaction.
A significant finding, by contrast, is an issue that should have been addressed but would not change the lending decision. For example, if a loan was priced using a FICO score of 750 but the correct score was 720, and the borrower qualified for the same terms, the discrepancy would not affect the outcome.
This additional review provides another opportunity to identify errors, validate key information, and improve the consistency of our underwriting decisions. AI serves as a valuable safeguard, helping our team catch potential oversights while keeping the final decision grounded in a comprehensive assessment of the borrower and transaction.
Why AI Alone Is Not Enough
Automated underwriting can efficiently analyze information, identify patterns, and flag potential risks. However, it may not fully understand the circumstances surrounding a particular borrower or loan. For example, a borrower may have a FICO score of 650 but previously paid off multiple loans with RFG and consistently made every payment on time. Because many private lenders do not report loan activity to the major credit bureaus, that successful repayment history may not appear on the borrower’s credit report.
An automated system reviewing only the available credit data could miss this important piece of the story. An experienced underwriter, on the other hand, can consider the borrower’s established relationship with RFG alongside the other elements of the loan application.
This is where the human touch makes a meaningful difference. AI can help us identify what the numbers show, while our team can evaluate the broader context and apply experience and judgment to the decision.
Building Partnerships, Not Just Making Loans
At RFG, we strive to be a partner to our borrowers rather than simply another lender. That philosophy influences how we evaluate loan applications and how we work with borrowers throughout the lending process. Combining manual underwriting with AI allows us to balance efficiency with a thoughtful, individualized approach to risk. Automation supports our team by identifying potential issues and validating information, while experienced underwriters provide the context and judgment needed to make sound lending decisions.
Ultimately, successful underwriting is about more than reviewing numbers or checking boxes. It is about understanding the borrower, evaluating the property, identifying potential risks, and making informed decisions that support responsible lending.
By bringing technology and human expertise together, RFG aims to deliver an underwriting process that is both efficient and thorough—strengthening our risk management while enhancing the borrower experience from origination through servicing. We believe the best results come when automation and human judgment work in harmony.

